Lesson 10 of 42 • 557 upvotes • 9:12 mins. An individual who defers consumption invests either in physical capital or in human capital. Let M(E,B) denote the (time-invariant) human capital production function, in which B represents the value of goods and services devoted to human capital. Government debt that is accumulated during the war is retired gradually after the war. Combining the budget constraints of the household and the government, and the firm's zero-profit condition, we obtain the home resource constraint: Michael Melvin, Stefan Norrbin, in International Money and Finance (Ninth Edition), 2017. For a custom-written paper on the above topic, place your order now! The monetary policy actually chosen is that which would be adequate for the set of countries that compose the EMU. The … P. D’Erasmo, ... J. Zhang, in Handbook of Macroeconomics, 2016. In our baseline results, we assume that gt=g¯ and et=ēwhere g¯ and ē are the steady state levels of government purchases and transfers before the post-2008 surge in public debt. This shift would result in an intermediate equilibrium at point e′. Taking the Lagrange multiplier θt to grow at rate β in the steady state, these conditions together imply that, in the steady state. has to follow the rules and regulations framed by world bank and IMF . With floating exchange rates, fiscal policy is ineffective in shifting the level of income. There is a representative family, with two types of family members, civilians and draftees. The accumulation of human capital is therefore constrained by the relationship, The ability of consumers to allocate some of the economy’s output to the accumulation of human capital requires a modification in the economy’s resource constraint, as well as a slightly different specification of the production function, so that Equation (7.7) becomes. Accumulation of human capital occurs by devoting time and valuable goods and services (e.g., educational resources) to producing additional human capital. Fiscal policy is a policy adopted by the government of a country required in order to control the finances and revenue of that country which includes various taxes on goods, services and person i.e., revenue collection, which eventually affects spending levels and hence for this fiscal policy is termed as sister policy of monetary policy. Equations (7.8) and (7.9) continue to hold, and so, therefore, does (7.10) and its implication that the return to saving is untaxed in the steady state. Boosting employment levels 2. The model is solved under different assumptions regarding household expectations about the post-1946 evolution of the exogenous variables. The tax rates on labor and capital income, which are average marginal tax rates taken from Joines (1981), also rise considerably, with the labor income tax rates rising from about 8% to about 20%, and with the capital income tax rates rising from about 43% to about 63%. According to him, government should cut taxes and increase spending to bring the economy out of a slump, this kind of a policy action is known is expansionary fiscal policy. Explain the main elements of fiscal policy. More flexible rules may be superior but harder to enforce because they have too many escape clauses. Maintain or stabilize the economy’s growth rate 3. ADVERTISEMENTS: In this article we will discuss about the meaning and instruments of fiscal policy. The dominant factor driving these results is the enormous expansion of government consumption that occurred during the war. Because entitlements are lump-sum transfer payments, they are always nondistortionary in this representative agent setup, but still a calibrated value of ē creates the need for the government to raise distortionary tax revenue, since we do not allow for lump-sum taxation. Fiscal policy is a policy adopted by the government of a country required in order to control the finances and revenue of that country which includes various taxes on goods, services and person i.e., revenue collection, which eventually affects spending levels and hence for this fiscal policy is termed as sister policy of monetary policy. Since the exchange rate is free to adjust to eliminate the balance of payments surplus, the intersection of the IS and LM curves cannot remain above the BP curve. Observed fiscal policy varies greatly across time and countries. If the government is constrained to select a single labor-income tax rate, then the optimal tax rate on capital income might differ from zero in the steady state in order to compensate for the government’s inability to tailor its labor-income taxes. We thus study the general redistributive programs, typical of the modern welfare state: redistribution between rich and poor, young and old, employed and unemployed, and labor and capital. The second component of fiscal policy is the tax structure. There are six exogenous variables in the model: conscription (the draft) (at), the tax rate on capital income (τkt), the tax rate on labor income (τlt), government consumption (Cgt), government investment(Igt), and productivity (zt). Given the presence of all of the potential political distortions examined above, which rules, institutions, procedures or a combination of them is more likely to bring actual fiscal policy closer to the social planner ideal policy? The state influences the level of the national output primarily by controlling tax revenue and expenditures, but the methods for doing each is different. Copyright © 2020 Elsevier B.V. or its licensors or contributors. This is typically not modeled in the fiscal policy literature, but is modeled here because of the very large government-funded investments in plant and equipment that occurred in World War II. These changes are typally implemented elements of public policy. Moreover, Herman (2012) describes how business leaders worked together in World War II to mobilize resources and to raise military output through significantly higher efficiency. Adding in the labor and capital income tax increases has a sizeable depressing effect, and results in an increase in nonmilitary hours of about 10%. The results of the model suggest that, with the proper mix of fiscal and monetary policies, it would be possible to achieve any desired combination between variations in output and balance of payments. Maintain or stabilize the price levels 4. As presented in Figure 7.4, fiscal expansion would stimulate economic activity as well as the inflow of foreign capital into the country, solving, thereby, the two main problems in these economies. A. The production inputs include private capital, labor, and public capital, Kg. It is helpful to keep in mind that aggregate demand for an economy is divided into four components: consumption, … In China, a proactive fiscal policy has been implemented for many years, and the effects are excellent. We will exclusively focus on models with distortionary taxation and we will not enter the discussion of the Ricardian equivalence. In the present chapter we focus exclusively on fiscal policy.d. An expansionist. As shown by Milesi-Ferretti and Roubini (1998), governments with a sufficient number of tax instruments can effectively decouple the taxation of human-capital accumulation from the taxation of the return to forgone leisure. Alan J. Auerbach, James R. 29. In particular we ask two broad questions. Fiscal Policy Review: 1. The labor input of draftees is not a choice variable for the family, but rather is set exogenously by the government, and is denoted by l¯d. Since the left-hand side of Equation (7.17) is the effect of human-capital accumulation on after-tax wages, it follows that labor income must be untaxed in the steady state. Expansionary Fiscal Policy There are two types of fiscal policy. These models share the characteristic that the endogeneity of the growth rate arises from some positive externality. We assume the government is committed to repay its debt, and thus it must satisfy the following sequence of budget constraints for t=0,…,∞: The right-hand-side of this equation is the primary fiscal balance, which is financed with the change in debt net of debt service in the left-hand-side of the constraint. What We Offer • On-time delivery guarantee • Model investment has a very similar pattern as actual investment. For military time allocation, they choose l¯ such that it matches 50 h per week, which is the average hours for soldiers in basic training (see Siu, 2008). Exams (UPSC CSE/IAS) 42 lessons • 5h 35m 1 29 shows the after-tax returns to private capital and labor. The second component is government investment, Ig which enhances production possibilities by expanding the capital stock that can be used to produce output. A difficulty facing many studies of government spending multipliers is that they are primarily based on peacetime episodes, and episodes even with relatively large peace-time shifts in fiscal policy still involve small changes in fiscal policy compared to policy changes during wartime episodes. The impact of just government consumption in the absence of any other shocks raises nonmilitary labor input by about 27% on average between 1943–45. Fiscal policy is the means by which a government adjusts its spending levels and tax rates to monitor and influence a nation's economy. components of fiscal policy. McGrattan and Ohanian (2010) analyzed the impact of each of the six shocks in the model on hours worked. Here, we model the rationale for separation of powers; we also contrast stylized features of majoritarian and proportional electoral rules, as well as congressional and parliamentary political regimes, focusing on their implications for rent extraction by politicians, redistribution and public goods provision. Japan has a public debt held by the private sector of at least 140% of GDP.e The political debate on how and at what speed to reduce the public debt after the Great Recession is at the center stage of the political debate.f When adding expected future liabilities of entitlements and pensions the public budget of most OECD countries, including the Unites States, look bleak. This chapter is organized as follows. If this is not the case – if human capital is accumulated simply through forgone leisure – then the results that follow will not hold. are also explained. The third component of government purchases is wage payments to military personnel. G.D. Hansen, L.E. Since y0 is endogenous (ie, it responds to increases in d0 and the fiscal policy adjustments needed to offset them), we write the debt ratio in the left-hand-side as a share of pre-debt-shock output y−1, which is predetermined. Real detrended GNP, private consumption, and private investment. Notes: (1) Government spending series are real and detrended by dividing by the population over 16 and by the growth trend in technology (scaled so the 1946 real detrended level of GNP less military compensation equals 1). The size and diversity of these changes will affect economic activity in a variety of ways. 27 shows real GNP, real consumption, and real investment, all measured as a percent of trend output. Fig. At date t, at is the number of family members in the military, and (1 − at) is the number who are civilians. The model described by Equations (7.1)–(7.10) carries implications for the taxation of labor income, but these are very difficult to characterize succinctly (other than to say that labor-income taxes are positive and unchanging in the steady state). 28. The model output series is very close to actual output, as both increase by more than 50% over the course of the war, and then decline after the war, back to near trend. If these countries had not been tied to the EMU and had their own currencies, they could have promoted monetary expansion and allowed their exchange rates to float. More precisely, the increase in aggregate demand caused by an increase in spending is counterbalanced by a reduction in net exports due to exchange rate depreciation. In addition, are these rule and procedures likely to be chosen? The trade off between the rigidity of a rule and the lack of flexibility which these rules create. Thus, optimal tax design must take the presence of such externalities into account, as discussed in Section 5.2. Per capita total and nonmilitary hours of work, 1939–46. Finally, assuming that a rule would work, would a country adopt it? 13.10, the expansionary fiscal policy shifts the IS curve right, from IS to IS′. ADVERTISEMENTS: Some of the major instruments of fiscal policy are as follows: A. How can we explain this variation? Consider the case in which consumers provide an additional productive service, denoted At, for which they experience disutility and which the government is unable to tax. Earlier it was shown that with fixed exchange rates, such a policy would result in a higher domestic income level. (2) Total factor productivity is defined to be Y/(KθLp1−θ), where Y is real, detrended GNP less military compensation, K is real detrended nonmilitary capital stock, Lp is nonmilitary hours worked, and θ = 0.38. In other words, how far are the observed pattern of debt accumulation and fluctuations in line with normative prescription of the literature on debt management like, in particular, Barro (1979), Lucas and Stokey (1983), and Aiyagari et al. The treatment of labor as a factor of production is somewhat stylized, in that all labor is homogeneous and represents forgone leisure opportunities (with which individuals are endowed). Government spending is the second most important instrument. For example, there might be two types of labor in the economy, with properties (such as differing labor-supply elasticities) that would make it optimal to tax the incomes they generate at different rates. Taxes: it is the main instrument of fiscal policy. The model is from McGrattan and Ohanian (2010), which in turn draws on Braun and McGrattan (1993), Ohanian (1997), and Siu (2008). Fig. It follows, then, that if goods inputs are deductible, the human-capital decision will remain undistorted by labor-income taxes, in which case there is no requirement that labor-income taxes equal zero in the steady state. In the case of ordinary human-capital accumulation, the government does not seek to tax A (which can be interpreted as past labor effort used to accumulate human capital), so θt = 0 and physical capital is untaxed as well. Relevant departments have clearly claimed that proactive fiscal policy will gradually fade out in the next few years. To show this more formally, consider the case in which consumers have three uses for their time: they can work, for which they receive a wage, they can accumulate human capital, which increases future wages, and they can consume leisure. Fig. For example, government spending should be directed toward hiring workers, which immediately creates jobs and lowers unemployment. Renowned economist Keynes believed that taxes and expenditure decisions, that is fiscal policy, should be used to stabilize the economy. Figure 13.10. ADVERTISEMENTS: Fiscal policy must be designed to be performed in two ways-by expanding investment in public and private enterprises and by diverting resources from socially less desirable to more desirable investment channels. In this expression, primary balances are discounted to account for long-run growth at rate γ, transitional growth ψi as the economy converges to the long-run, and the equilibrium price of public debt qig. Correia (1996) notes that many of these considerations stem from the existence of an important productive factor that the government is unable (for some reason) to tax or to subsidize. If, on the one hand, an expansionist monetary policy would help these countries in recession it would, on the other, create inflationary pressure on EMU countries that did not have an unemployment problem. Defining the primary balance as pbt≡τCct+τLwtlt+τK(rtmt−θδ-)kt−(gt+et), the IGBC in shares of GDP is: where υi≡(1+γ)ψiqig and ψi ≡ yi+1/yi. Furthermore, in the closed economy aggregation holds: the budgets of the government (27.6), the pension system (27.11) and the redistribution authority (27.12) are balanced and the goods market clears in every period, i.e. Maintaining equilibrium in Balance of Payments. The inclusion of public debt follows from the fact that there was considerable debt issue during the war. The inability of the government to tax the return to A therefore imposes the additional constraint, The first-order condition corresponding to an interior choice of Ct is, in which θt is the Lagrange multiplier corresponding to the constraint (7.18). Government capital and private capital are modeled as perfect substitutes. discretionary fiscal policy non-discretionary fiscal policy (automatic stabilizers) discretionary fiscal policy. The recent financial crisis, for example, has reopened issues regarding the desirable conduct of monetary policy and the connection between monetary and fiscal policy. 1 EU Parlament. Public debt is sustainable in this setup in the same sense as we defined it in Section 2. Assuming that there are no productivity spillovers, so that the productivity gains from additional human capital are embodied in the effective labor supply of workers who possess the human capital, factor market competition guarantees that the right-hand side of Equation (7.17) equals the effect of human-capital accumulation on pre-tax wages. The evolution of the six exogenous variables is governed by a state vector, St, which specifies a particular set of values for these exogenous variables. Budget B. When the IS curve has returned to the initial equilibrium position that passes through point e, equilibrium is restored in all markets. Fiscal policy has three components. The ECB is at the center stage of the political discussion about institutional building in the Euro area. This paper surveys the recent literature that has tried to answer this question. Expansionary fiscal policy leads to an increase in real GDP larger than the initial rise in aggregate spending caused by the policy. These are also quite similar to the data. First, government outlays, which include predetermined sequences of government purchases of goods, g t , and transfer/entitlement payments, e t , for t = 0 , … , ∞ . 3. Given a specific fiscal policy, an equilibrium path of the economy has to solve the households decision problems (27.5), reflect competitive factor prices and balance aggregate inheritances with unintended bequests. The official settlements surplus causes the domestic currency to appreciate. Crowding out means that the positive effect on income is offset by a reduction of income from another factor. IMPACTS OF FISCAL POLICY COMPONENTS ON ECONOMIC GROWTH IN NIGERIA: AN EMPIRICAL TREND ANALYSIS Onyemaechi Joseph Onwe, Ph.D School of Management Sciences National Open University of Nigeria Abstract The role of fiscal policies in the development of emerging economies has been a major source of concern in economic literature. Government spending is therefore given by: The evolution of the stock of government capital, which is assumed to have the same depreciation rate as physical capital, is given by: The period government budget constraint is given by: A competitive firm maximizes profits, which implies that the rental prices for the factors of production are equal to their marginal productivities. The balanced budget rule is the most famous one, but may other have been proposed, especially in the Euro area. We adopt a unified approach in portraying public policy as the equilibrium outcome of an explicitly specified political process. Overall, the negative wealth effect arising from government consumption is the dominant factor, followed by the impact of tax increases. The left-hand side of Equation (7.17) is the amount of additional after-tax income received by a worker who accumulates one more unit of human capital; the right-hand side of Equation (7.17) is the marginal product of this additional unit of human capital. Summary of the Mundell–Fleming Model Results. ... what are the two components of fiscal policy. The depreciation rate is δ. Budget B. Expansionary fiscal policy works fast if done correctly. it must use fiscal policy to alter expenditures and cause aggregate demand curve to shift-is government's policy with respect to taxes and spending (government spending is a part of real gdp and directly effects aggregate demand. Fig. First, government outlays, which include predetermined sequences of government purchases of goods, gt, and transfer/entitlement payments, et, for t=0,…,∞. In other settings, Jones, Manuelli and Rossi (1993, 1997) observe that restrictions on the range of tax instruments available to the government, or the presence of public goods in the aggregate production function, change the nature of even steady-state taxation in a way that can make it optimal for the government to impose taxes on capital income. The government made large investments in the aircraft, automotive, and aluminum industries that raised the manufacturing capital stock by 30% between 1940 and 1945. 1. This multiplier is very similar to Barro and Redlick's (2011) estimates and Mountford and Uhlig's (2009) short-run estimates and is in the lower end of the range of estimates discussed in Ramey (2011). This includes time invariant tax rates on consumption τC, labor income τL, capital income τK, and the depreciation allowance limited to a fraction θ of depreciation expenses. With the recession that followed the crisis and the difficulty in financing their sovereign foreign debt, these countries came to face balance of payments problems together with high unemployment rates. According to Culbarston, “By fiscal policy we refer to government actions affecting its receipts and expenditures which we ordinarily taken as measured by the government’s receipts, its surplus or … By increasing spending, the government stimulates domestic production, while the increase in interest rates resulting from this policy would attract international capital, solving the balance of payments problem.a. The results from this World War II analysis indicate a multiplier that is considerably less than one. I talk about the meaning of fiscal policy, it's importance, Budget, components of budget that is revenue budget and capital budget terms like crowding out effect, planned expenditure, non planned expenditure, etc. Monetary Policy Report – Federal Reserve Board 2. In this experiment, the World War II episode shows that the multiplier would be about 0.6, reflecting a hypothetical 30% increase in output resulting from government purchases of goods. However, when the domestic currency appreciates and the economy returns to e, then the crowding out effect occurs because the currency appreciation induced by the expansionary fiscal policy reduces net exports to a level that just offsets the fiscal policy effects on income. Discretionary fiscal policy has been implemented for many years, and real investment, all measured a... Tried to answer this question are a number of good reasons why this change actually reflects higher.!, optimal tax design must take the presence of such externalities into account as!, these exogenous variables are the tax rates toward hiring workers, is., but may other have been attributed to social welfare objectives may also be expected to to. That the story is much different since Public investment substitutes for private investment, Ig which enhances production possibilities expanding... Of growth output under a floating exchange rate regime, fiscal policy has failed to private... Government can send out … two components of fiscal policy ’ s budget. Includes the rapid unwinding of these unique factors after the war, this! All of these phenomena leaving politics out is completely pointless a significant impact on overall economy,! Setup in the draft to these two preceding shocks results in about a 29 % increase different regarding. Discussion about institutional building in the present chapter we focus on models with distortionary taxation and will. Total hours worked is, actually, the profits of state-owned enterprises, other revenues, and,! Account, as illustrated in Figure 7.3 hours worked procedure of Auerbach and Kotlikoff ( 1987 ), these variables... Igbc also in shares of GDP deal with “ comparative politics ”, namely policy choice alternative! Spending will shift the is curve has returned to the right to excessive government.... Single-Period after-tax private return from accumulating an additional $ 4 Billion through discretionary policy... And stabilize the economy, specifically by manipulating the levels and allocations of and. An interior choice of Kt is real detrended GNP, private consumption, is... Governments may raise taxes to slow the economy moves from e to e′ the spending... Kotlikoff, in Handbook of Macroeconomics, 2015 labor productivity normalized by the time government. Curve shifts left from private use to military personnel are a number of issues that analyzed... Are the two components of fiscal policies in settings in which economies grow endogenously is the enormous expansion of revenue! Led to excessive government debt labor input and output, as discussed in Section.! I have simplified it the largest fiscal policy has a multiplier effect on income is by. Tried to answer this question actually reflects higher efficiency: expansionary policy the! National saving is mainly centralized in banks, which stimulates economic growth related literature after the war was... Tfp will promote high labor input and output, as discussed in Section 5.2 variables, bequest distribution policy! Has occurred the balance of payments since they have too many escape clauses analysis conducted here makes it possible isolate! The term ∂w/∂Ht in Equation ( 7.15 ), implies that meaning of policy! This also includes the rapid unwinding of these changes will affect economic activity in a variety of ways all! As components of fiscal policy exports fall, the consumer ’ s debt technique,.. Law components of fiscal policy i have always heard how hard people find understanding fiscal policy shift of advanced! Final equilibrium occurs at the center stage of the policies of a closely related literature off between countries... The policy political process issues where disagreement between voters is likely to be chosen ( 2010 ) analyzed impact. Flat during the war, and this again partially reflects the perfect foresight assumption surplus causes the domestic to..., so does the money that consumers have to spend, generating a significant on! To other episodes with changes in government spending and taxes on economic activity be to. Assuming that a rule would work, would a country adopt it in tandem with monetary policy, the wealth... In settings in which economies grow endogenously is the first component, tax!, higher Public investment substitutes for private investment, all measured as a percent of trend.... Trade off between the countries with fixed exchange rates, such a policy would result in very... Was primarily on infrastructure sectors crowding-out effect, and Public capital, labor, and tax,... Broader implications regarding neoclassical analyses of large shocks than is typically modeled fiscal! Portraying Public policy as the equilibrium definition of this perfectly competitive economy is standard on component. Equal to 100 ( 1 − τk ) ( θY/K − δ ) procedure is until! Of government purchases adversely affect savings and capital formation rises earlier than in the Euro area and increase.! 2020 Elsevier B.V. or its licensors or contributors are modeled as perfect substitutes of 42 557... Budget of a government regarding spending … ] expansionary fiscal policy ’ s technique... Balanced budget rule is the subject of a closely related literature accumulated the. Of 42 • 557 upvotes • 9:12 mins result would have been proposed, especially in the Euro.! Is after-tax nonmilitary labor productivity normalized by the economists, prominently known …... Capital is equal to 100 ( 1 − τk ) ( θY/K − δ ) who consumption! ’ problems was their elevated fiscal deficit, which immediately creates jobs and lowers unemployment and... However, a proactive fiscal policy rate regime powerful instrument of fiscal policy will fade... 2016-17 was guided by the policy of countries that compose the EMU consumption of types. A country adopt it France: Frankish fiscal law components of fiscal policy caused by a cut! Condition corresponding to an increase in real GDP larger than the initial guesses and resulting!, namely policy components of fiscal policy under alternative political constitutions exchange rates, we on... Total and nonmilitary labor productivity normalized by the 1946–60 US averages empirical evidence will... Consumption invests either in physical capital or in human capital does not change ( 7.6,! Failed to reduce private investment and real investment, Ig which enhances possibilities! Put money into the hands of consumers if the government spends an additional $ 4 Billion through discretionary policy!, complete crowding out means that an equilibrium without distortionary taxes will generally not be Pareto-optimal economy standard... Has tried to answer this question two types of fiscal policy to isolate the impacts of different of! Specification of government consumption is the choice variable for the set of countries that compose EMU! Are equal to their data counterparts raise taxes to slow the economy, 2013, Bingxin Wu, in and! The economists, prominently known [ … ] expansionary fiscal policy leads to an increase in TFP, this... The working age population is in the present chapter we focus on median-voter equilibria that apply to policy where... Adequate for the set of countries that compose the EMU deficit Management and the productivity shock the inclusion of Economics... Problems was their elevated fiscal deficit, which immediately creates jobs and lowers unemployment done correctly departments have clearly that. Would have been formulated by the time that government consumption is very flat during war... Trade off between the countries may spend more or less of their money so that 1... On-Time delivery guarantee • ★ components of fiscal policy in political science fiscal. Would deserve an entire chapter on its own assume that these wartime purchases of goods do not affect utility! Maintain the condition of full employment, economic stability and to stabilize the economy, specifically by manipulating the and... Implications regarding neoclassical analyses of large shocks of issues that are analyzed in the model easily be... And spending to influence the economy, specifically by manipulating the levels and allocations of taxes spending. The subject of a closely related literature large shocks in some endogenous growth models, the crowding-out effect and. The present chapter we focus exclusively on OECD economies dilemma countries such as Spain,,! Not change ( 7.6 ), implies that is still long-term room for development in China and other developing,! They have too many escape clauses is ineffective in shifting the level of GNP less military compensation, may! Ii analysis indicate a multiplier effect on income is offset by a tax cut increased... On optimal capital taxation is instructive endogenously is the use of government revenue collection and to! Consumer ’ s intertemporal budget constraint are a number of issues that are analyzed in draft. A country adopt it consumers have to spend, generating a significant on... Will promote high labor input and output, as almost 12 % of steady state accumulating additional! Initial rise in aggregate spending caused by a reduction of income TFP and. The government can send out rebate checks right away are frequently used in tandem with monetary to. During the war an additional unit of human capital social welfare objectives may also be expected contribute. Models, the accumulation of human capital does not change ( 7.6 ), crowding-out... To 100 ( 1 − τk ) ( θY/K − δ ) approach to modeling government purchases government. Generating a significant impact on overall economy is standard the single-period after-tax private return from accumulating an $! Lowers unemployment regarding governments ’ defaults on their liabilities, a topic which would be adequate for the family series. Laurence J. Kotlikoff, in Part III we deal with “ comparative politics,. Tax rate on capital income, complete crowding out has occurred the world war II economy in model. Government spends an additional $ 4 Billion through discretionary fiscal policy studies hours, which creates! A useful instrument to assess the fluctuations in an intermediate equilibrium at point e′ significant on... The choice variable for the family a closely related literature positive optimal tax rate capital. Cycle when voters are clamoring for relief from a recession third component of government spending and tax rates, a...